Create a free Diverse: Issues In Higher Education account to continue reading

Beyond Academia: Recognizing and Supporting Non-Academic Struggles of Ph.D. Students

Kiarra Boenitz

As the pursuit of higher education becomes increasingly competitive and demanding, the focus on academic achievements often overshadows the personal battles that many Ph.D. students face behind the scenes. While the journey toward a doctoral degree is celebrated for its intellectual rigor and scholarly contributions, it's time to shine a spotlight on the non-academic struggles that often go unnoticed.

One such challenge is the intersection of chronic illnesses and mental health issues with academic life.

In the renowned memoir, Lab Girl, authored by Hope Jahren, the narrative candidly explores Jahren's battles with bipolar disorder amidst her scientific pursuits. This introspective account serves as a poignant reminder of the profound impact personal challenges, such as mental health issues, can have on one's academic journey.

Kiarra BoenitzKiarra BoenitzAdditionally, scholarly discourse on the intersection of graduate education and mental health, exemplified by J. Blake's article, "Graduate School and Mental Illness: A Survey of Strategies for Support," underscores the prevalence of mental health struggles among graduate students. The research elucidates the inadequacies in institutional support systems, prompting critical reflections on the broader academic landscape's approach to addressing such issues.

These literary and scholarly examples collectively illuminate the often overlooked personal battles that Ph.D. students face, particularly concerning chronic illnesses and mental health challenges. Such insights underscore the imperative to prioritize holistic support structures within academia to foster student well-being and academic success.

As a Ph.D. student recently diagnosed with Eosinophilic Esophagitis (EOE), I've experienced firsthand the delicate balancing act required to manage my personal health alongside the demands of my academic pursuits. From navigating dietary restrictions to coping with debilitating symptoms, the impact of EOE on my daily life cannot be understated.

Unfortunately, my experience is not unique. Many Ph.D. students grapple with chronic illnesses and mental health concerns, yet the stigma surrounding these issues often discourages open dialogue and support. The prevailing narrative of academia glorifies productivity and resilience while overlooking the human aspect of our experiences.

Regrettably, my journey mirrors that of numerous Ph.D. students grappling with chronic illnesses and mental health concerns. One such example is Emily, a dedicated colleague who battles with Crohn’s disease. Despite her remarkable perseverance, the debilitating symptoms often disrupt her academic pursuits, leading to periods of extended absences and reduced productivity. Unfortunately, the prevailing stigma surrounding chronic illnesses can amplify feelings of isolation and hinder Emily’s ability to seek the support she desperately needs from her peers and advisors.

Moreover, the lack of institutional support exacerbates the challenges faced by students like me. While universities offer resources for academic success, there is often a dearth of support specifically tailored to addressing non-academic struggles. Accessible healthcare services, mental health counseling, and accommodations for individuals with chronic illnesses are essential components of a supportive academic environment, yet they remain elusive for many students.

Why?

The stigma surrounding accommodations for chronic illness and the lack of discussion about the non-academic side of academia are deeply entrenched issues within the academic community. This stigma often stems from misconceptions and stereotypes about chronic illnesses and mental health issues, perpetuating a culture where individuals feel reluctant to openly address their non-academic struggles.

In many academic cultures, there's an unspoken expectation to prioritize productivity and academic achievement above all else, which can create pressure to hide or minimize personal challenges. This emphasis on resilience and achievement can make it difficult for individuals to seek accommodations for chronic illnesses or to discuss mental health concerns, fearing judgment or professional consequences.

Furthermore, there's often a lack of awareness and understanding about chronic illnesses and mental health issues among academics, leading to misconceptions and stigma. Without proper education and support, individuals may not know how to advocate for their needs or access the resources available to them.

Additionally, institutional barriers, such as inadequate policies and support systems, can further exacerbate the problem. Without proper accommodations and resources in place, individuals may feel unsupported and discouraged from seeking assistance.

Addressing these systemic shortcomings necessitates a paradigm shift within academia, one that prioritizes holistic support structures tailored to address the diverse needs of students. Only through concerted efforts to destigmatize chronic illnesses and mental health concerns, coupled with tangible policy changes aimed at fostering inclusivity and support, can we truly cultivate an environment where all students thrive academically and personally.

To do this, individuals in all levels of academia must support students. It’s within our capability to individually destigmatize discussions around non-academic struggles and prioritize the well-being of graduate students.

Changing academic culture to be more inclusive and accommodating necessitates bold and proactive steps. We must collaboratively implement comprehensive support systems that cater to the diverse needs of students. This includes peer support networks, advocation, and the promotion of a community culture that prioritizes self-care and work-life balance.

In conclusion, the non-academic struggles of Ph.D. students, including chronic illnesses and mental health issues, deserves greater recognition and support within academia. It's time to shift the narrative away from productivity at all costs and toward a more compassionate and inclusive approach to graduate education. By prioritizing the well-being of students, we can foster a more equitable and supportive academic environment for all.

Kiarra Boenitz is a Ph.D. student in higher education and student affairs at Indiana University Bloomington.

A New Track: Fostering Diversity and Equity in Athletics
American sport has always served as a platform for resistance and has been measured and critiqued by how it responds in critical moments of racial and social crises.
Read More
A New Track: Fostering Diversity and Equity in Athletics