Create a free Diverse: Issues In Higher Education account to continue reading

Napolitano to Protect Border Better, Holder To Break With Bush Administration on Torture


President-elect Barack Obama’s pick to oversee Homeland Security told senators she will improve the department’s operations and relationships with other agencies, while his choice for the Attorney General’s office forcefully broke from the Bush administration’s counterterrorism policies.

In testimony prepared for delivery at her confirmation hearing, Arizona Governor Janet Napolitano cites challenges the department faces in fending off terrorist attacks and preparing for emergencies and natural disasters.

Among them, she says, are having to operate out of 70 buildings at 40 different locations in the Washington region and low morale in a work force that is 40 percent contract employees.

The Homeland Security Department was formed after the 9/11 terrorist attacks from 22 federal agencies.

Declaring that water-boarding is torture and pledging to prosecute some Guantanamo Bay detainees in U.S. courts, Holder signaled that President Obama will chart a new course in combating terrorism. As recently as last week, Vice President Dick Cheney defended water-boarding, a harsh interrogation tactic that simulates drowning, saying it provided valuable intelligence.

The CIA has used the tactic on at least three terrorism suspects, included alleged Sept. 11 mastermind Khalid Sheikh Mohammed. In past hearings, Attorney General Michael Mukasey and his predecessor, Alberto Gonzales, frustrated senators by repeatedly sidestepping questions about water-boarding.

It was the first topic discussed at Holder’s confirmation hearing, and he made an unambiguous statement about its nature: “Water-boarding is torture.”

The declaration sent a wave of approval through the public viewing gallery, where protesters, dressed in orange prison scrubs like those worn by detainees at the Guantanamo Bay military prison, held signs calling for an end to torture.

As a practical matter, Holder said torture does not lead to reliable intelligence. And on principle, he said the United States needs to live up to its own high standards, even in the face of fear and terrorism.

“The decisions that were made by a prior administration were difficult ones. It is an easy thing for somebody to look back in hindsight and be critical of the decisions that were made,” Holder said. “Having said that, the president-elect and I are both disturbed by what we have seen and what we have heard.”

Holder appeared headed for confirmation, as Democrats are in the majority and Republicans held off from the toughest questioning. After Holder agreed that the nation is at war, Sen. Lindsey Graham, R-S.C., quipped: “I’m almost ready to vote for you right now.” He later said he looked forward to working with Holder.

Obama counts Holder among his most trusted confidants. As attorney general, he will take a lead role carrying out one of Obama’s signature campaign promises: closing Guantanamo Bay. Obama has described the naval prison as a “sad chapter in American history.” He plans to issue an executive order calling for the prison to be closed.

Holder echoed that stance Thursday but said shuttering the prison would be difficult and would take time. Many detainees could be transferred to other countries, he said, and some could be charged and jailed in the U.S. That is a contentious proposal because many oppose the idea of bringing terrorism suspects onto U.S. soil.

The incoming Obama administration has not indicated what would happen to the detainees who were transferred to the United States. Holder said the administration was considering prosecuting the detainees in civilian courts, military courts or in some new hybrid court.

“I think we want to leave our options open,” Holder said. “The one thing I can assure you and the American people and, frankly, the world is that whatever system we use, it will be consistent with our values. It will be a system that has due process guarantees. It will be seen as fair.”

He also did not have an answer to how the new administration would handle detainees deemed too dangerous to release but who could not be prosecuted without endangering CIA operatives or jeopardizing intelligence methods.

Holder promised to be an independent attorney general, telling lawmakers that he did not believe the attorney general’s job was to serve as the president’s lawyer — a frequent criticism of Gonzales’ tenure under President George W. Bush. He also pledged to restore the independence of a Justice Department where Bush administration appointees used political benchmarks when making hiring decisions.

“One of the things I’m going to have to do as attorney general in short order is basically do a damage assessment,” Holder said.

In the days leading up to the hearing, it appeared the GOP would grill Holder as a show of strength following big Democratic wins on Election Day. But Holder was largely spared any confrontational questions for most of the daylong hearing.

After Holder issued his opinion on water-boarding, Republican Sen. Arlen Specter turned the questioning briefly toward the 2001 pardon of fugitive financier Marc Rich. Holder, who was the No. 2 official at the Justice Department at the time, told the White House that he was neutral, leaning toward favoring the pardon. On Thursday, Holder repeated an apology, saying he regrets not studying the pardon more.

But Holder said he learned from the mistake and would be a better attorney general because of the experience.

Sen. Jeff Sessions, R-Ala., later questioned Holder about his role in President Clinton’s decision to grant clemency to Puerto Rican separatists involved in the deadly 1982 bombing of a Manhattan federal building. The 16 members of the Armed Forces of National Liberation served 19 years in prison before the clemency was awarded.

Though human rights groups applauded the decision, lawmakers from both parties criticized the move. Holder said Thursday that it was a difficult decision for Clinton but described it as “reasonable,” contending that those released from prison did not carry out the violent acts. Former FBI officials have disputed that view.

If confirmed, Holder would be the nation’s first African-American attorney general. No Republican has announced plans to oppose Holder’s nomination.

Email the editor: [email protected]

Click here to post and read comments

© Copyright 2005 by

A New Track: Fostering Diversity and Equity in Athletics
American sport has always served as a platform for resistance and has been measured and critiqued by how it responds in critical moments of racial and social crises.
Read More
A New Track: Fostering Diversity and Equity in Athletics