Create a free Diverse: Issues In Higher Education account to continue reading

Fisk’s Sale of Priceless O’Keeffe Painting at Bargain Price Blocked by Tennessee Attorney General

Fisk University’s proposed sale of a priceless Georgia O’Keeffe painting at a fire-sale price, was blocked today by the Tennessee Attorney General, who said the sale would be “an artistic and financial loss for Fisk and would detract from the rich cultural environment of this community.”

Attorney General Robert E. Cooper Jr. blocked a deal in which Fisk would get $7 million for a prized O’Keeffe painting, that could fetch three times that amount on the open market, from the Georgia O’Keeffe Museum, which would then free the school to sell other works it had been given by the late O’Keeffe.

“It seems more appropriate to seek greater resolution of the legal issues from the Court and to determine the degree of flexibility that Fisk can exercise in its stewardship of the Stieglitz Collection than to approve a one-sided settlement,” Cooper wrote in a three-page letter to lawyers for Fisk, in Nashville, and the Georgia O’Keeffe Museum, in Santa Fe.

Fisk had no immediate comment on the attorney general’s ruling.

 A July 18 hearing in the Chancery Court of Nashville has been set to hear a request from Fisk for a declaratory judgment that Fisk is the sole owner and can do what it wants with the O’Keeffe painting, the most valuable of the 101 pieces in the Stieglitz Collection.

The O’Keeffe Museum has challenged Fisk’s claims in court, asserting the school is barred from selling any parts of the collection by covenants agreed to in the 1940s when the late Ms. O’Keeffe donated the collection to the school.

The museum agreed this winter to drop its challenge and free Fisk to sell any part of the collection it wanted, except the O’Keeffe painting. In exchange for dropping its legal challenge and giving Fisk $ 7 million over time, the museum would get that painting — “Radiator Building – Night, New York.”

Fisk officials have been criticized by art scholars for trying to unload the key parts of the  Stieglitz Collection. When details of its deal with the O’Keeffe Museum became public, criticism grew louder because the sale price was so low. Still, no local or state officials or civic leaders in Tennessee came forth with a plan to block the deal and save the collection for Fisk and the city.

When the proposed settlement was presented to the attorney general in February,  Cooper indicated he was inclined to approve the deal to help Fisk solve its financial problems. He delayed a final decision, however, asserting he felt it was in the interest of the state and the school to find local parties in Tennessee who would help the school keep the priceless collection in keeping with the wishes of the donor, Ms. O’Keeffe. Under Tennessee law, the attorney general represents the interest of the people of the state in supervising the beneficiaries of charitable gifts. 

During that cooling off period, Fisk said it received no offers of substances from Tennessee or Nashville leaders but had gotten several offers for Radiator Building from legitimate art dealers offering more than $20 million for the painting. The school also learned “Painting No.3,” by Marsden Hartley, another jewel in the Stieglitz Collection, would also bring as much as $20 million, if sold on the open market.

Cooper, whose approval of the sale was considered the last roadblock the school needed to sell the art, said the new information made it clear “…the $7 million purchase price offered by the Museum (for the O’Keeffe painting) is simply too deep a discount from the apparent market price value for this Office to approve.”

Cooper said his decision should in no way affect the short term operations of Fisk, noting that the school had told him the art sale was to address the school’s “long term financial stability.” 

In admonishing the school to work harder to keep the collection, Cooper reiterated his position articulated in his February letter to the parties, saying …”the importance and significance of the Stieglitz Collection to Nashville’s art community and to historically Black colleges and universities cannot be overstated.”

Hazel O’Leary, president of Fisk for the past three years, has made sale of the O’Keeffe painting and “Painting No. 3” by Marsden Hartley, the centerpiece of her plan to raise money for the school and replenish its endowment.

The endowment was drained by some $8 million — nearly half its total — to cover operating expenses in the years before O’Leary’s tenure. In previous statements, O’Leary has vowed Fisk will win the right to sell the art works, asserting the small liberal arts college is not a museum but a school.

Beyond the art sale and stepped up alumni giving appeals, Fisk has not articulated a grand plan for fundraising from local, state or national sources.

© Copyright 2005 by

The trusted source for all job seekers
We have an extensive variety of listings for both academic and non-academic positions at postsecondary institutions.
Read More
The trusted source for all job seekers